MAILCRAFT
Home Features Pricing About Blog Contact Log in Get Started →
Email automationEmail marketingMarketing automation

Mailchimp vs ConvertKit vs ActiveCampaign: Email Tools Ranked

Tablet showing a yearly calendar on a wooden desk next to a keyboard, a phone and a spiral notebook with a pen

Which email marketing tool should a small business pick? This ranking of email tools gives the short answer: Mailchimp suits a simple start with many marketing features in one dashboard, ConvertKit suits creators selling courses and newsletters, and ActiveCampaign suits companies that run marketing and sales from one CRM.

If you sell in Europe, care about GDPR and need your emails to land in the inbox rather than spam, Mailcraft is the strongest alternative. Below you will find the criteria, a profile of each tool, a quick match by situation and the traps to check before you buy.

This is the Mailcraft blog, so we say it plainly: where a competitor is the better fit, we tell you.

How we built this ranking of email tools

We rank the tools by fit for a small business, not by the length of their feature lists. We do not rank on price, because plans change every few months, and we do not quote tests we never ran. We picture an online shop, a service business, a B2B company with one marketer and an owner who writes the newsletter alone. Each tool is judged on five questions:

  • Can you send the first campaign quickly without a developer?
  • Are automations such as a welcome series or a win-back reminder included in a plan a small business can afford?
  • Who controls your sender reputation, and can you have your own sending domain and a dedicated IP?
  • How does the tool support GDPR: consent, double opt-in, unsubscribes, data export, a data processing agreement?
  • Does it connect to what your business runs on, for example WordPress or PrestaShop?

If you are still deciding whether email deserves budget at all, read how email marketing as an owned channel is changing. The order below reflects a typical small business in the EU, yet every tool has a reader for whom it is the first choice.

Best email marketing tools for small business: who wins?

In our own ranking (we are not neutral here), for a small business selling in Poland or elsewhere in Europe, Mailcraft takes first place, Mailchimp second, ActiveCampaign third and ConvertKit fourth. Mailcraft wins on deliverability and GDPR, while the other email tools lead in their own niches.

1. Mailcraft: when the inbox and GDPR matter most

Mailcraft is an email marketing platform built in Poland around deliverability. Sending runs on Mailcraft’s own infrastructure, and a setup wizard walks you through SPF, DKIM and DMARC and your own sending domain. The Business plan includes a dedicated IP, a sender reputation you do not share with other customers, while the Pro plan uses a reputable shared pool. We explain the trade-off in our piece on dedicated vs shared IPs for deliverability.

The second advantage is GDPR by design: double opt-in, unsubscribes, data export and consent management are built in. Shops get WordPress and PrestaShop plugins and a Shoper integration in beta. Add conditional segmentation, tags and custom fields, and you can see the full list on the Mailcraft features page.

Limits: Mailcraft is not a suite with a website builder, ads and a sales CRM. Automations come with the Pro and Business plans, not with the entry Starter plan. An AI assistant (rewriting and translating content, subject line variants, an email drafted from a short brief) comes with the Business plan and higher.

2. Mailchimp: when you want a familiar all-in-one tool

Mailchimp is the best-known brand here and a good pick for a business that wants newsletters, landing pages and basic CRM features in one dashboard. It has a large template library, many ready-made integrations and plenty of tutorials, so answers are easy to find.

The weaker points for a small European business: it is a US vendor, so you check the data processing agreement and transfers outside the EU yourself, and you should model plan costs as your list grows. More advanced automations sit in higher plans.

3. ActiveCampaign: when marketing and sales work together

ActiveCampaign has the deepest automation in this ranking: conditions, branching, lead scoring, site tracking and a CRM with a sales pipeline. It fits a B2B company where a salesperson wants to see what a contact opened and clicked before calling.

The price of that power is time. Someone has to build, monitor and fix the workflows, and without that person most of the features go unused. It is also a US vendor, so the GDPR questions match those for Mailchimp.

4. ConvertKit: when you are a creator or a solo business

ConvertKit, now operating under the Kit brand, was built for creators: authors of newsletters, courses and digital products. Subscribers are managed with tags, automations are simple and visual, and selling digital products is built in.

For a shop with physical products or a service business it is rarely the first pick. Templates are minimal on purpose, and integrations with local shop platforms need checking separately.

Which tool should you choose? A quick match by situation

Start from what should happen after someone joins your list. Find your situation below:

  • Shop on PrestaShop or WordPress with EU customers: Mailcraft, for its plugins, consent tools and control over deliverability.
  • Creator newsletter, online course or e-book: ConvertKit, because it is simple and sells digital products.
  • B2B company with a sales team and a long sales cycle: ActiveCampaign, provided someone owns the automations.
  • First newsletter and many marketing tools in one place: Mailchimp.
  • You send regularly and more mail lands in spam: Mailcraft, ideally on a plan with a dedicated IP.

If you are torn between two tools, pick the one that solves your biggest problem today. For a detailed look at automation, segmentation, deliverability and GDPR, read our separate Mailchimp vs ConvertKit vs ActiveCampaign comparison.

Example: a small shop that wants more than a newsletter

Picture a cosmetics shop on PrestaShop run by two people. Once a month it sends a promotion to the whole list and is considering a welcome series and a reminder for customers who have not bought in a while.

That shop needs three things: a plugin that moves sign-ups from the shop to the list, a few automations triggered by sign-up or by date, and confidence that consent meets GDPR. In Mailcraft it gets this on the Pro plan: the PrestaShop plugin, a visual workflow builder with sign-up, tag, date and field change triggers, and double opt-in. With Mailchimp the same shop would also manage, but it checks the PrestaShop integration and the data processing agreement separately. ActiveCampaign would be overkill, and ConvertKit is not designed for a shop with physical products.

What to watch out for when choosing an email tool

Most disappointments come from things the homepage comparison does not show. Before you buy, check:

  • whether automations are in the plan you buy or only in a higher one,
  • whether you send from a shared IP pool or can have your own IP and sending domain,
  • where subscriber data is stored and whether the vendor signs a data processing agreement,
  • whether you can export the list with tags and fields if you switch later,
  • whether migration from your current tool is included or is your job.

Mailcraft has no free trial; every plan has a 14-day money-back guarantee and Pro includes free migration, as described in the Mailcraft plans and pricing. Whatever tool you test, send a real campaign to a small part of your list first. For the wider strategy behind the tool, see our email marketing guide with best practices.

Our ranking of email tools comes down to one piece of advice: choose for your market and your biggest problem. If you sell in the EU and want control over deliverability and consent, start on a monthly Mailcraft plan, connect your domain and send the first campaign to a small segment before you move the whole list.

FAQ

Which email marketing tool is best for a small business?

There is no single winner. For a shop or service business in Europe that cares about GDPR and deliverability, Mailcraft is a strong choice. A course creator will prefer ConvertKit, and a B2B company with a sales team ActiveCampaign.

Can US email tools be used under GDPR?

Yes, but as the data controller you check the data processing agreement and the legal basis for transfers outside the EU. Ask each vendor where subscriber data is physically stored and which subprocessors it uses.

Can I move my list from Mailchimp to another tool?

Yes. You export the list to a CSV file and import it into the new tool with field mapping, which Mailcraft supports. Automations and templates usually have to be rebuilt, so plan the move for a quieter period.

Where should I start with my first newsletter?

Start with a sign-up form with double opt-in, a welcome series and one regular send. Any of these four email tools can handle that start, so choose by what you will need in a year: automation, control over deliverability or a CRM.